🍔 Best Burger Joints Near New Buffalo

1. Redamak’s Tavern

📍 616 E Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Locally owned by the Maroney family since 1975. A menu full of American staples, from apps to dinners and a full bar full of fun cocktails. A legendary burger joint, Redamak’s is a must-visit for anyone craving a juicy, cheesy, and satisfying burger. Their famous "Cheddar Cheeseburger" is a melt-in-your-mouth delight, and their crinkle-cut fries are the perfect sidekick.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Cheddar Cheeseburger – A New Buffalo classic

• Fried Pickles – The perfect salty, tangy snack

• Onion Rings – Crispy, golden, and addictive

Open Thursday to Monday from Noon to 9pm Closed Tuesday and Wednesday's

2. Casey’s New Buffalo

📍 136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Think Royal Oak, Ann Arbor-type vibes, but without the hustle and bustle. You've got a menu filled with juicy meals from seafood to steak, and pastas to salads. The stand-out feature here is their wide open patio space! Perfect for those Michigan summer days. Casey’s offers gourmet burgers, wood-fired pizzas, and craft beer—perfect for satisfying your munchies. Their truffle fries and loaded mac & cheese are must-tries.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Casey’s Classic Burger – Topped with bacon, cheddar, and house sauce

• Truffle Fries – Crispy fries with parmesan and truffle oil

• Buffalo Chicken Pizza – A spicy, cheesy masterpiece

Open from noon to midnight Sunday through Thursday. Open late until 2am on Friday's and Saturdays

🍕 Pizza & Comfort Food Cravings

3. Stray Dog Bar & Grill

📍 245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
When you've got the munchies and craving some top-tier tacos... you CANNOT go wrong here. The tacos and other menu items are all the rave, but the rooftop bar gives you a scenery that is SO gas. A laid-back spot with killer pizzas, burgers, and tacos. Their nachos and loaded fries are perfect for sharing when the munchies hit.

🔥 Must-Try:

• BBQ Chicken Pizza – Sweet, smoky, and cheesy

• Loaded Nachos – Piled high with cheese, jalapeños, and sour cream

• Buffalo Chicken Wrap – Spicy, crispy, and oh-so-good

Open 7 days a week from noon til 11pm

4. Brewster’s Italian Café

📍 11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Wood fired pizzas? Sauces, dips, dressings, and desserts made all in-house? Pasta that's fresh-to-death? YES PLEASE!!! Maybe considered a little shfancy... but switching out your sweat pants for some jeans is 100% worth it here. If your munchies demand Italian comfort food, Brewster’s has you covered. Their handmade pasta, wood-fired pizzas, and garlic bread are irresistible.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Margherita Pizza – Fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato sauce

• Fettuccine Alfredo – Creamy, cheesy, and rich

• Garlic Knots – Soft, buttery, and packed with garlic flavor

Open everyday at 9am and closes up at 9pm during the week, 10pm on Friday and Saturday

🌮 Taco & Mexican Food Fix

5. Rosie’s Restaurant

📍 128 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Rosie’s is a hidden gem serving authentic Mexican food. Their tacos, burritos, and quesadillas are packed with flavor and perfect for munchies.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Carne Asada Tacos – Juicy steak, fresh cilantro, and onions

• Queso Fundido – Melted cheese dip with chorizo

• Churros – Crispy, sugary, and perfect for dessert

6. El Rancho Grande

📍 118 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
A local favorite for authentic Mexican flavors. Their enchiladas, fajitas, and margaritas are perfect for a late-night feast.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Steak Fajitas – Sizzling, flavorful, and filling

• Chicken Enchiladas – Smothered in red sauce and cheese

• Horchata – A sweet, cinnamon-infused drink

🍩 Sweet Treats & Desserts

7. Oink’s Dutch Treat

📍 227 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Who doesn't love a nostalgic walk-up ice cream parlor? With over 50 different ice cream flavors, nitro brew coffees, an oink-oink here, and an oink-oink there, this is THE summer munchies spot in New Buffalo

🔥 Must-Try:

• Superman Ice Cream – A colorful, fruity favorite

• Peanut Butter Cup Sundae – Loaded with chocolate and peanut butter

• Homemade Fudge – Rich, creamy, and perfect for sharing

Only open on weekends during the cold months. Friday 12 to 9pm Saturday 11:30am to 10pm and Sundays 11:30am to 8pm

Starting in early march they open their doors 7 days a week. You can even order online!

8. David’s Delicatessen & Coffee

📍 30 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
For a sweet and caffeinated pick-me-up, David’s offers fresh pastries, cookies, and lattes.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Cinnamon Rolls – Warm, gooey, and topped with icing

• Chocolate Chip Cookies – Freshly baked and chewy

• Caramel Latte – Sweet, creamy, and energizing

🍟 Late-Night & Fast Food Cravings

9. Jackie’s Café

📍 801 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
A cozy diner serving breakfast all day—perfect for when the munchies demand pancakes, waffles, and bacon. A wild and sassy mix of French and Asian Cuisines. Jackie Shen, a famous Chicago Chef, is the mastermind behind this cafe and does not disappoint. Breakfast and lunch staples along with Jackies 'Back Door' bakery. 

🔥 Must-Try:

• Banana Pancakes – Fluffy, sweet, and satisfying

• Bacon & Eggs – Classic and comforting

• French Toast – Thick, buttery, and topped with syrup

Open Wednesday to Sunday from 8am to 1:30pm

10. McDonald’s (Exit 1)

📍 18891 Harbor Country Dr, New Buffalo, MI 49117
Sometimes, you just need fast, greasy, and familiar. McDonald’s is perfect for late-night munchies.

🔥 Must-Try:

• Big Mac – A classic, satisfying burger

• McFlurry – Creamy, sweet, and loaded with toppings

• French Fries – Salty, crispy, and addictive

FAQ – Best Munchies Spots in New Buffalo

1. What is the best place for burgers in New Buffalo?

Redamak’s Tavern is the top choice for juicy, cheesy burgers that will satisfy any craving.

2. Where can I get late-night food near Exit 1?

McDonald’s and Jackie’s Café are great options for late-night munchies.

3. What’s the best pizza spot in New Buffalo?

Stray Dog Bar & Grill and Brewster’s Italian Café serve delicious, cheesy pizzas.

4. Where can I find the best Mexican food in New Buffalo?

Rosie’s Restaurant and El Rancho Grande offer authentic tacos, burritos, and enchiladas.

5. What’s the best place for dessert in New Buffalo?

Oink’s Dutch Treat has amazing ice cream and fudge, while David’s Delicatessen offers fresh pastries and coffee.

Conclusion

When the munchies hit, New Buffalo, Michigan, has plenty of delicious options near Exit 1 and US 12. Whether you’re craving burgers, pizza, tacos, or sweet treats, this guide ensures you’ll find the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings.